Ever felt like you're doing everything 'right' with your dog's training, but something still feels off? You're not alone. While dog training has evolved dramatically over the years, certain outdated myths continue to circulate, creating needless stress for both dogs and their humans. Today, we're tackling three persistent myths that might be undermining your progress—and more importantly, showing you what actually works for real dogs in real homes.
Myth 1: “You need to make your dog sit and wait before you open the door.”
This myth originates from the outdated training approach known as “Nothing in Life Is Free” (NILIF), which suggests dogs should earn everything through specific behaviors. While it’s true that asking your dog to sit and wait before exiting can be useful in certain scenarios, such as preventing door-darting on a busy street, it’s not necessary for every dog or every situation.
For instance, if you live on a busy street and your dog tends to dart out the door, teaching a “wait” behavior could prevent a potentially dangerous situation. However, if you live in a quiet neighborhood or have a secure yard, insisting on a sit-and-wait routine every time you open the door might be unnecessary.
The Reality:
It’s perfectly fine to let your dog out without requiring them to perform a behavior first. Training should fit the needs of your dog and your household, not adhere rigidly to outdated protocols. Dogs don’t need to “earn” access to basic freedoms, and it’s okay to let them enjoy life without always asking for something in return. Focus on teaching behaviors that serve a specific purpose, such as safety, rather than feeling obligated to follow arbitrary rules.
Myth 2: “It’s not OK to choose management as the solution.”
There’s a pervasive idea that using management strategies—like crates, baby gates, or leashes—is a sign of failure or a temporary fix. Some owners feel pressured to train away every behavior, even if those behaviors can be safely and effectively managed with tools or adjustments to the environment.
For example, if your dog tends to bark excessively at the doorbell, you might feel the need to spend hours desensitizing them to the sound. While this can be effective, it’s also perfectly fine to use management solutions, such as placing your dog in another room when expecting visitors, to prevent the behavior from escalating.
The Reality:
Management is a valid and often humane approach to behavior challenges. You get to decide what’s most important for you and your dog. If managing a behavior effectively meets both your needs, additional training may not be necessary. For example, using a baby gate to block access to the front door can prevent door-darting or jumping on guests, offering peace of mind without extensive training. Management and training aren’t mutually exclusive; they can work hand-in-hand to create a safe and happy environment for both you and your dog.
Myth 3: “Counterconditioning and desensitization are always the answer to aggression.”
Counterconditioning and desensitization are powerful, evidence-based techniques for addressing aggression and fear-based behaviors. These methods work by gradually changing a dog’s emotional response to a trigger. However, they aren’t always the first step—especially if the root cause of your dog’s aggression is pain or an underlying medical issue.
Pain can be a significant factor in many behavior problems, including aggression. For example, a dog that growls or snaps when touched might not be exhibiting aggression due to fear or frustration but because they are experiencing physical discomfort. If pain is the root cause, jumping straight into behavior modification without addressing the medical issue can worsen the problem.
The Reality:
Before beginning any behavior modification plan, it’s crucial to rule out medical issues. A visit to the veterinarian should always be your first step if your dog’s behavior has suddenly changed or escalated. Once you’ve addressed any underlying health problems, counterconditioning and desensitization can be highly effective. However, they will only succeed if your dog is physically comfortable and able to engage in the process.
Why These Myths Persist
These myths often persist because they were once widely promoted as standard practices in dog training. “Nothing in Life Is Free” protocols gained popularity for their structure, and the emphasis on training over management appealed to owners seeking long-term solutions. Similarly, counterconditioning and desensitization are frequently recommended because they are evidence-based—but without the proper context, even the best tools can be misapplied.
As our understanding of dog behavior grows, it’s important to question these assumptions and adapt our approaches to meet the individual needs of each dog.
Tailoring Training to Your Dog
The key takeaway from debunking these myths is that dog training isn’t one-size-fits-all. Every dog is unique, and effective training involves understanding their specific needs, triggers, and circumstances. Here are some general tips for tailoring your approach:
1. Assess Your Dog’s Needs:
Consider your dog’s environment, behavior, and personality when deciding whether training, management, or a combination of both is the best approach.
2. Focus on Safety First:
Whether it’s teaching a “wait” at the door or using a leash and harness during walks, prioritize safety for both you and your dog.
3. Consult Professionals:
If you’re unsure about the root cause of your dog’s behavior, seek guidance from a veterinarian or a skilled behavior professional to ensure you’re addressing the issue effectively.
4. Be Flexible:
Don’t feel pressured to follow rigid rules. Adapt your training and management strategies as your dog grows, changes, and learns.
Conclusion
Like many aspects of living with dogs, training isn't about following a rigid set of rules—it's about building a relationship that works for both of you. Now that you understand the reality behind these common myths, you can let go of the 'should's' and 'must-do's' that might have been adding unnecessary pressure to your training journey. Whether you choose to ditch the doorway sits, embrace management solutions, or prioritize a vet visit before diving into behavior modification, remember: the best training approach is one that considers your dog's individual needs, your lifestyle, and the unique dynamic you share. Your instincts about your dog matter, and sometimes the most effective solution is the one that simply makes both of your lives easier and happier.
Want more myth-busting insights and practical training advice delivered straight to your inbox? Join my free monthly newsletter where I share bite-sized training tips and real-world behavior solutions. Each issue is packed with actionable advice you can use right away with your dog—no fluff, just helpful content that actually works. Click here to join my community of thoughtful dog lovers.
Ready to move beyond the myths and create a training approach perfectly tailored to you and your dog? My bespoke coaching program helps you cut through the confusion and develop strategies that fit your specific situation, lifestyle, and goals. No more second-guessing or trying to force one-size-fits-all solutions. Click here to learn how we can work together to build a stronger, more joy-filled relationship with your dog.
Comments